Upon the former defender took over as the club's head coach in the winter, there was scant opportunity to find his feet. A congested run of games meant a slow onboarding to his squad was simply not feasible.
Local press pointed out the challenges he would encounter, especially overseeing a locker room packed with some of football's largest egos.
However forging positive connections with the squad members did not seem to faze the ex- Liverpool full-back.
"It's not an aspect that concerns me a lot," Arbeloa said at his inaugural news conference.
Two months later, he claims those rapports are strengthening and the performances on the pitch are following.
Building Connections
During the spring, Arbeloa guided his side to victories against sides led by elite managers: the Portuguese manager's Benfica, the Catalan's Manchester City and the Argentine's Atletico Madrid.
Los Merengues continue to be four points behind the Spanish league leaders Barcelona, with a potentially title-deciding El Clasico in the spring, while their European campaign continues with a last-eight tie against Bayern Munich.
The team's form are getting better and the chemistry between the manager and squad are building.
"I am becoming to know the players more and more," commented the head coach after his team's 3-2 success against rivals Atletico recently.
"I arrived at a juncture when I practically had no time to work with the squad, to see where they operated best, and to see how they interacted with one another."
He admitted the circumstances of his appointment posed new challenges.
"For me, it's difficult to come in the middle of the campaign and analyze how the squad operates, and that's what has evolved over these past eight weeks," he added.
"Now I understand my charges on and off the pitch, where I can extract the optimal output from them, and where I can make adjustments."
Acclaim for Vinicius Jr
One player excelling under Arbeloa is the Brazilian winger.
He has started 16 of his new coach's 17 games at the helm, with his output also seeing a dramatic uptick - he has netted 11 times under the current boss, as opposed to scoring just six in 27 outings under his predecessor.
The coach has focused on rebuilding the attacker's confidence, urging him to play freely and be creative rather than restricting him in terms of tactics.
"I'm lucky to have Vinicius, he's loved by all the fans. We want to see the Vini who enjoys playing, who laughs, who dances… that is the player I want to see," Arbeloa said in his initial press conference in charge.
This method stands in opposition to accounts of strain under Alonso, with the forward reportedly saying "I will quit this team" after being substituted in last match against Barcelona.
Arbeloa has publicly supported him, stating clearly he is completely supported by the coaches and the entire squad.
"He is among the deadliest players, if not number one, in the world today and he embodies what a Real Madrid star is," added the manager.
The Brazilian put discussions about his future at the club on hold last summer but, recently, he stated his desire to stay clear.
"I am solely focused on this club and staying there for a very long time," he told the media before Brazil's friendly with the French team.
Valverde Recaptures His Best Form Again
The Uruguayan midfielder's form has also improved dramatically since Arbeloa took charge.
During the tenure of Alonso, he registered three strikes and seven assists from 31 appearances.
Ever since Arbeloa's appointment, Valverde has been named in the starting eleven for each of the 17 of his matches in charge, scoring seven times and providing five assists.
A key factor has been a tactical repositioning to his natural place in midfield.
During the former coach's time in charge, Valverde at times had difficulty trying to cement a starting spot in his preferred position, being positioned in unusual positions such as right-back.
Although the decision was partly due to fitness issues to teammates, Valverde's frustration was clear. "I wasn't born to be a defender," he remarked.
But now, back in his favored role, Valverde is thriving.
He has scored six goals in just a month, featuring a three-goal haul against Manchester City and a crucial goal in a 3–2 win over their city rivals.
Youth Integration, Greater Possibilities?
The manager's experience as manager of the club's reserve team has made incorporating academy talents into the senior side feel effortless, so it was logical to anticipate him to give emerging talent opportunities.
This occurred more notably when Real Madrid faced Elche earlier this month and Arbeloa gave minutes to six youth team players.
One player, in particular, has swiftly established himself as one of the manager's most promising disciples.
At just 18 years of age and 226 days, he made history as the most youthful player in the team's history to begin a match twice in the European Cup latter stages, beating Vinicius' record by 10 days.
Asked what it signified to see several youth products on the field, Arbeloa couldn't mask his pride.
"I believe I can die happy after a evening like tonight," he stated.
"I was just speaking with some of them, who were the first players I coached when they were very young, and to be able to give them the chance to perform at the Santiago Bernabeu is a lifelong dream realized for me."
Although Arbeloa might be familiar with the youth team members, he concedes injuries have restricted his exposure